overlaylink

The New York Times Is Wrong About Science Fiction

Harrison Cook
November 21, 2024 | 4 min read

Even though it’s four years old now, the 2021 New York Times article claiming H.G. Wells invented the genre of science fiction still makes the rounds on social media, sparking outrage, push-back, and splitting literary hairs.

You know the literary type: we’re well-read and love citing sources and, well, being right. I’m speaking from experience here. And that’s why I’m confident telling you that The New York Times forgot about this little book called Frankenstein.

Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus fused elements of romanticism and the gothic to create a tale many call gothic horror. But her fascination with the technology of the day (like electricity that ran through tesla coils) pushed her imagination and her writing to create a future devoid of death. Her seminal novel examines how this complicates the mortal coil.

What if anyone could reanimate a loved one or create an amalgam of dead body parts? What soul occupies the new body? What does it say about the consciousness of the scientist who pursues such endeavors?

That is pure science fiction.

Check out the inspiration behind Frankenstein and the biographical details that paint a clearer picture of Mary Shelley, the true pioneer of science fiction!

You know the literary type: we’re well-read and love citing sources and, well, being right. I’m speaking from experience here. And that’s why I’m confident telling you that The New York Times forgot about this little book called Frankenstein.

Mary Shelley Had an Interesting Childhood

Mary Shelley was raised by her father, a political journalist and philosopher, and was often encouraged to write despite not receiving a formal education. Her father often kept the company of leading intellectuals of the day, which inspired Shelley’s storytelling.

While there is a lot of Mary Shelley lore, which is hard to separate from the truth at times, Shelley’s life was as dark, gothic, and passion-filled as the horror she wrote.

Let’s address the elephant in the room — yes, it’s more than likely that Mary Shelley lost her V-card with her soon-to-be husband, Percy Shelley, at her mother’s grave. There’s a lot to unpack there.

Percy was a poet, so it was almost expected of him to do overtly crazy things, and Mary did lose her mom ten days after being born, so maybe she gets a pass too.

However, the parallel between Mary Shelley and her fictional Victor Frankenstein is clear, given that in the novel, Dr. Frankenstein often supplements his anatomy and chemistry lessons by digging up graves and comparing their parts.

In every fiction, there is something real, and in everything real, there is some fiction.

The Science That Made Frankenstein’s Monster

Eighteenth and ninteenth-century scientific theory is wild but also held some surprising truths. Galvanism, a leading scientific branch at the time, suggested the body’s electrical framework could be flipped back “on” when a current was reintroduced into the body’s chemicals — which led to the belief you could reanimate the body under the right conditions and with the right materials.

Mary and Percy Shelley would see a scientific demonstration of this principle in a traveling symposium — an event wonderfully stylized in the bioflick Mary Shelley starring Elle Fanning. Here, the scientists would supercharge a metal rod and then press it on the skin of a dead frog, which would “magically” kick back to life.

A modern reader, of course, knows this is simply an electric current causing the corpse’s muscles to contract. But place yourself in the audience of this symposium and imagine seeing a dead frog kick — it would be the stuff of mad science, the stuff of novels!

There was a greater dialogue between the arts and sciences back then, too, which often painted the heralds of discovery as equal parts fervent passion and fearful power. This clearly serves as a blueprint for the doctor himself.

In the novel, Dr. Frankenstein references Benjamin Franklin’s famous key-and-kite experiment to test the path of lightning currents. There’s even some speculation on the two figures sharing the same five letters in their last name.

There was a greater dialogue between the arts and sciences back then, too, which often painted the heralds of discovery as equal parts fervent passion and fearful power.

The Writing Sleepover

Another legendary setting: the sleepover-turned-writing-contest that produced The Modern Prometheus. Lord Byron; John Polidori, Byron's personal physician; and Percy and Mary Shelley tasked one another with writing a ghost story while escaping the summer rain in Switzerland.

Mary would initially write a short story version of Frankenstein, which would later be developed and edited by Percy Shelley. Lord Byron wrote the beginnings of a vampire short story and Polidori expanded that into a novel called The Vampyre. It’s thought that Percy started a short story about his childhood but abandoned it to work on a collection of poems.

While several literary works were produced on that trip, only one truly stands the test of time through countless reimaginations and adaptations. Think of the depressed teens making the “perfect” boyfriend in Lisa Frankenstein, and experiments in learning what it means to be human-like, as in Poor Things.

The relationship between the creator and what’s created, an archetype used to create the science fiction genre by Mary Shelley, never fails to disappoint.

In Conclusion

We should probably give an overworked NYT writer and editor a break. Maybe.

Here’s the rub: while Wells certainly helped shape the genre of science fiction, the article breezed past one key pioneer of sci-fi, Mary Shelley. By the time H.G. Wells was born in 1866, Shelley’s Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus had been published for 48 years.

It’s high time we stop erasing the contributions of women writers from our collective literary history. Period.

Think of it this way: Frankenstein’s monster ran (or lumbered) so Wells's Martians could plan their earthly invasion.

Think of it this way: Frankenstein’s monster ran (or lumbered) so Wells's Martians could plan their earthly invasion.

--

Resources

Audrey Shafer, MD. “Why Issues Raised in Frankenstein Still Matter 200 Years Later.” Stanford Medicine Magazine, 1 Feb. 2024, stanmed.stanford.edu/why-issues-raised-in-frankenstein-still-matter-200-years-later.
Reef, Catherine. Mary Shelley: The Strange, True Tale of Frankenstein’s Creator. Clarion Books, 2018.
“The Story of Mary Shelley.” The Queen’s Reading Room, 10 Nov. 2023, thequeensreadingroom.co.uk/the-story-of-mary-shelley.
July 08, 2025 3 min read

How does a USA Today bestselling author use Freewrite? Chelsea Conradt takes us inside her writing process.

June 19, 2025 4 min read

What's a romance author to do when a global pandemic hits?

For Carolina Flórez-Cerchiaro, the answer was to start writing horror.

Carolina was writing romance when she first signed with her literary agent six years ago. But, Carolina explains, when the pandemic hit, she pivoted to horror.

"There was something about being isolated at home, living through the literal nightmare that COVID-19 was, that made me want to dive into a haunted house book," she explains. And it's a good thing she did.

That horror novel, Bochica, sold to Simon & Schuster at auction. (Trust us, it's a big deal.)

In fact, switching genres changed her life in more ways than one. "Writing Bochica made me want to move to an old manor in the woods," Carolina says, "so I now live in a house that I’m pretty sure is haunted."

Read on to learn how this Freewriter uses her four-year-old Freewrite Traveler to draft.

ANNIE COSBY: What does your writing process look like?

CAROLINA FLÓREZ-CERCHIARO: My writing process varies depending on the project, but generally, I start with some brainstorming before drafting. I’m not a heavy outliner, but I do make a rough roadmap — usually marking where the character starts, the midpoint, and a general idea of the ending.

It’s often just a list of bullet points to give me some structure. I don’t always know how I’ll get from point A to point B, and the outline changes as I go. I usually re-outline after drafting to make better sense of the story. I don’t treat the outline as strict — I let myself get lost in the story once I’m in it.

It’s really important for me to get the words on the page, even if they’re messy. You can’t edit a blank page, and revising is actually my favorite part of the process. So I focus on finishing that first draft so I can dig into the part I enjoy most.

For projects like Bochica where the historical backdrop is essential, I research before drafting, and continue to do so while writing and revising.

"I don’t treat the outline as strict — I let myself get lost in the story once I’m in it."

AC: How long did it take you to write Bochica?

CFC: The first draft took me about three months to write, and I revised it for another six to eight months with my agent before we sold it to my editor.

AC: That's really fast! How did Freewrite factor into your writing process?

CFC: My Freewrite Traveler is an essential part of my writing process, for every project I work on. It helps me get the juices flowing when I’m stuck, but it also helps me get those words on the page faster. I call it my little magical device!

I not only use it when I draft, but also when I’m revising, and I need to rewrite or add new passages, chapters, or scenes. I use it ALL the time.

"I call [Traveler] my little magical device!"

AC: Why do you prefer to draft on a Freewrite?

CFC: There’s a literal freedom that I get from using it as I’m drafting, similar to when I write by hand, but way more convenient. It’s quick, it keeps me off the internet, and I can easily upload it to my computer!

AC: Let's dig into your publishing journey. How did Bochica get published?

CFC: Bochica isn’t the first book I ever wrote, and it’s also not the book that got me my agent. I was actually writing romance when I signed with my literary agent almost six years ago, and when the pandemic hit, I decided to pivot into writing horror which had always been my favorite genre to read.

When the book was ready for editors, my agent sent it out, and I got an initial offer within days, then we got more offers, and the book ended up selling at auction to Simon and Schuster.

"Writing Bochica made me want to move to an old manor in the woods, so I now live in a house that I’m pretty sure is haunted."

AC: How has the publishing process been so far?

CFC: It’s been quite an experience; you go from hitting the lowest point to feeling on cloud nine the next second.

To sum it up in one word: WILD.

I’m lucky to have an amazing team behind me, both with my literary agent, and with my publishing team at Atria/Primero Sueño Press, to help me navigate this road, to get through the good, and the bad.

"[Publishing] has been quite an experience; you go from hitting the lowest point to feeling on cloud nine the next second."

AC: And before we sign off, what is Bochica about?

CFC: After her father is accused of murder, a young woman returns to her haunted childhood home — turned luxury hotel — and is forced to face the sinister shadows of her past, and unearth the truth of her mother’s mysterious death.

Think Mexican Gothic meets The Shining.

AC: Wow. I'm in!

If Bochica sounds like a wild ride to you, too, check it out here

June 10, 2025 12 min read

Discover the best tenkeyless mechanical keyboards for 2025. Compact, durable, and perfect for any setup - check out our top picks for gaming and productivity.